Wrong Contract in the Right Hand by Jan van Cleeff


Suppose you pick up as South:

spade Q 7 4 heart Q 8 3 diamond A K J 4 club 10 7 4

West is the dealer, nobody vulnerable. Christine van der Ven from the Netherlands encountered an uncharacteristic bidding problem.

West North East South
Christine

Pass 1NT Pass 3NT
Dble 4club Pass ??

West's double asks for a spade lead. Christine elected to bid 4diamond that was passed out. This was the complete deal:

spade 8 6 3 2
heart A 2
diamond Q 7
club A K Q 9 2
spade A K J 10 5 spade 9
heart K 6 5 heart J 10 9 7 4
diamond 6 5 3 diamond 10 9 8 2
club 6 5 club J 8 3
spade Q 7 4
heart Q 8 3
diamond A K J 4
club 10 7 4

West led two top spades and let her partner ruff a third spade. With the clubs 3-2 the diamond partscore turned out to be a claim. Still, North-South were not happy, since 3NT by South was cold. However, the board turned out to be a 1 IMP gain, since the North-South pair at the other table played in 3club from the North hand. East led her singleton spade, and four rounds of the suit promoted the clubJ, holding declarer to nine tricks. This defence would have defeated a contract of 4club so you see it is better to opt for your 4-2 fit.

Results Contents
Teams, Round 10
Teams, Round 11
Teams, Round 12
Teams, Round 13
Teams, Semifinals
From the Commentators table
Question Time, by Jan van Cleef
Know your System
Wrong Contract in the Right Hand
Down the Wire
The Prize you pay for possible brilliancy



Return to Top of page To Front Page