Even Homer Nods by Marc Smith


Board 12. Dealer West. NS Game
spade K J 6 3
heart K 10 9 6 4 2
diamond 9
club K 2
spade Q 10 9 spade A 8 7 5 4
heart A 7 heart
diamond A 5 diamond K Q J 10 4
club A Q J 10 9 3 club 7 5 4
spade S
heart Q J 8 5 3
diamond 8 7 6 3 2
club 8 6

The following auctions before were typical…

West North East South
Levy Cohen

1club 1heart 1spade 3heart
Dble Pass 4spade All Pass

West North East South
Hackett Smith

1club 1heart 1spade Pass
2heart Pass 3diamond 4heart
4spade All Pass

Both declarers received a heart lead, won the Ace and played the Queen of spades. That was virtually the end of the hand whatever North did. E/W +650 for a fairly normal result… Not quite, for there were a number of rogue tables.

West North East South
Pagan Holowski Godfrey Nehmert

1club 1heart 1spade 3heart
4spade Pass 5heart Pass
6club Pass 6spade!!! All Pass

Most players who found themselves in a similar position to Britain's Lizzie Godfrey elected to settle for game in view of the poor quality of their spades, Partner's lack of a 4heart bid, and the known poor breaks (opponents are Vulnerable and they have bid a lot with no points).

Godfrey decided to bid on, with the result that Ian Pagan was able to bid a slam missed consistently around the room. Unfortunately for Pagan, partner was still there. It is certainly a strange decision for East to remove 6club looking at three-card support, a void in the opponents' suit, bad spades, and a source of tricks on which to discard West's spades.

At least Godfrey came to the same eleven tricks as most East players. This hand offers all aspiring players an excellent lesson - even the best players sometimes take their eye off the ball. Bep Vriend is a World Champion and the Netherlands' top woman player. She played the normal 4spade against Britain's Callaghan-Duckworth and received the usual heart lead. However, when she now tried Ace and another trump, the roof caved in on her. Brian Callaghan won his Jack of Spades and forced declarer with a second heart. When Vriend now took the loosing club finesse, Callaghan cashed his high trump, forced declarer's last trump, and now had the thirteenth trump and three heart winners left. 4spade-4 N/S +200.

Results Contents
Pairs 2nd Final/Consolation Session Pairs Final Session 2
French Encounter
Even Homer Nods, by Marc Smith
Unheard Melody



Return to Top of page To Front Page